Back
    Book Review

    When We Believed in Mermaids

    by Barbara O'Neal

    Read if you're interested in grief, relationships, or books for adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    4.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This novel follows Josie, whose life is upended when she sees her sister Kit, long thought dead by suicide, in a news report. The discovery leads Josie on a complex journey to uncover the truth about Kit's disappearance and the secrets that have been hidden for decades, exploring themes of grief, family secrets, and identity.

    What it does well
    • Explores themes of grief and loss, which can resonate with readers navigating similar experiences.
    • Highlights the enduring bonds of family, even through difficult circumstances.
    • Promotes perseverance and the search for truth, which are virtues.
    Watch for
    • The book contains mature themes, including implications of sexual content, though not always explicit, that may be uncomfortable for some Christian readers.
    • Mentions of drug use and alcohol consumption are present in the narrative.
    • The characters' moral compass and decision-making often deviate from biblical principles, particularly concerning honesty and relationships outside of marriage.
    Verdict

    Christian readers should approach this book with discernment. While it offers a compelling narrative and explores universal themes of family and loss, the mature content, character choices, and lack of a spiritual framework may not align with all Christian values. It could be read by those comfortable filtering content and engaging in critical analysis of secular perspectives on life's challenges.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers should approach this book with discernment. While it offers a compelling narrative and explores universal themes of family and loss, the mature content, character choices, and lack of a spiritual framework may not align with all Christian values. It could be read by those comfortable filtering content and engaging in critical analysis of secular perspectives on life's challenges.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores themes of grief and loss, which can resonate with readers navigating similar experiences.
    • Highlights the enduring bonds of family, even through difficult circumstances.
    • Promotes perseverance and the search for truth, which are virtues.
    Areas of concern
    • The book contains mature themes, including implications of sexual content, though not always explicit, that may be uncomfortable for some Christian readers.
    • Mentions of drug use and alcohol consumption are present in the narrative.
    • The characters' moral compass and decision-making often deviate from biblical principles, particularly concerning honesty and relationships outside of marriage.
    • While exploring redemption in a secular sense, it does not explicitly offer a path to spiritual redemption through Christ.
    • The focus is on secular life experiences and choices, without a spiritual dimension or reliance on faith for guidance.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…