Back
    Book Review

    When Santa Fell To Earth

    by Cornelia Funke

    Read if you're interested in faith, relationships, or books for child.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This children's fantasy novel portrays Santa Claus as one of the last true Christmas figures facing an evil business magnate who wants to commercialize Christmas. Two children, Charlotte and Ben, assist Santa and his loyal reindeer and elves in his struggle to bring genuine Christmas spirit back to the world.

    What it does well
    • Emphasizes themes of genuine giving and the spirit of Christmas over commercialism.
    • Promotes acts of kindness, generosity, and helping others.
    • Highlights the importance of imagination and believing in good things.
    Watch for
    • The magical and fantastical elements, while central to the story, are not rooted in biblical truth, which could be confusing for children regarding the source of true wonder.
    • The story inherently relies on the secular myth of Santa Claus, which can overshadow the biblical narrative of Christ's birth if not properly contextualized by parents.
    • The antagonist, Twirlix, is purely evil and driven by greed, which while a moral lesson, lacks recognition of any potential for redemption or the deeper struggle with sin.
    Verdict

    For Christian readers, this book can be enjoyed as a whimsical fantasy story that promotes positive values like generosity and kindness. However, parents should take the opportunity to discuss the true meaning of Christmas, emphasizing the birth of Jesus Christ, and gently differentiate between the fictional elements of Santa and the biblical truth.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    For Christian readers, this book can be enjoyed as a whimsical fantasy story that promotes positive values like generosity and kindness. However, parents should take the opportunity to discuss the true meaning of Christmas, emphasizing the birth of Jesus Christ, and gently differentiate between the fictional elements of Santa and the biblical truth.
    Biblical alignment
    • Emphasizes themes of genuine giving and the spirit of Christmas over commercialism.
    • Promotes acts of kindness, generosity, and helping others.
    • Highlights the importance of imagination and believing in good things.
    • Demonstrates the power of friendship and teamwork.
    • The 'true' Santa is depicted as benevolent and focused on children's happiness, aligning with positive archetypes of generosity.
    Areas of concern
    • The magical and fantastical elements, while central to the story, are not rooted in biblical truth, which could be confusing for children regarding the source of true wonder.
    • The story inherently relies on the secular myth of Santa Claus, which can overshadow the biblical narrative of Christ's birth if not properly contextualized by parents.
    • The antagonist, Twirlix, is purely evil and driven by greed, which while a moral lesson, lacks recognition of any potential for redemption or the deeper struggle with sin.
    • The book does not offer any direct references or allusions to the Christ child or the spiritual significance of Christmas.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…