Back
    Book Review

    West Side Story

    by Irving Shulman

    Read if you're interested in relationships, social issues, or books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    3.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    Irving Shulman's novelization of 'West Side Story' recounts the tragic love story of Tony and Maria, set against the backdrop of gang violence and racial tensions in 1950s New York City. The narrative explores themes of forbidden love, prejudice, and societal conflict, ultimately leading to a devastating conclusion.

    What it does well
    • Highlights the destructive nature of prejudice and discrimination, aligning with Christian calls for love and unity among all people.
    • Illustrates the longing for peace and escape from adversarial circumstances, echoing a desire for God's peace that surpasses understanding.
    • Shows the profound human cost of hatred and violence, serving as a cautionary tale.
    Watch for
    • Depiction of premarital sexual activity and intense romantic relationships that do not align with Biblical standards for purity and sexual ethics.
    • Extensive use of street language and profanity throughout the narrative.
    • Glorification of gang culture and violence, despite its ultimate tragic consequences.
    Verdict

    Christian readers should approach 'West Side Story' with discernment, recognizing its historical and cultural significance as a cautionary tale about prejudice and violence. While it can stimulate discussions on the destructiveness of hatred and the longing for peace, its mature themes, language, and non-Biblical worldview on relationships require a mature understanding to engage critically and not be swayed by its ungodly elements.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers should approach 'West Side Story' with discernment, recognizing its historical and cultural significance as a cautionary tale about prejudice and violence. While it can stimulate discussions on the destructiveness of hatred and the longing for peace, its mature themes, language, and non-Biblical worldview on relationships require a mature understanding to engage critically and not be swayed by its ungodly elements.
    Biblical alignment
    • Highlights the destructive nature of prejudice and discrimination, aligning with Christian calls for love and unity among all people.
    • Illustrates the longing for peace and escape from adversarial circumstances, echoing a desire for God's peace that surpasses understanding.
    • Shows the profound human cost of hatred and violence, serving as a cautionary tale.
    • Depicts sacrificial love, albeit in a secular context, which can prompt reflection on the ultimate sacrifice of Christ.
    Areas of concern
    • Depiction of premarital sexual activity and intense romantic relationships that do not align with Biblical standards for purity and sexual ethics.
    • Extensive use of street language and profanity throughout the narrative.
    • Glorification of gang culture and violence, despite its ultimate tragic consequences.
    • Lack of overt Christian themes or redemptive spiritual elements; solutions to conflict are sought within human means, often failing.
    • The tragic ending can feel nihilistic in a Christian worldview, as there's no clear message of hope for ultimate redemption or divine intervention.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…