Book Review
Then She Was Gone
by Lisa Jewell
Read if you're interested in grief, relationships, or books for adult.
Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
4.5
VerdictRead with discernment
Loading your rating…
Book Summary
This psychological thriller explores the aftermath of a teenage girl's disappearance and her mother's desperate search for answers a decade later. It delves into themes of grief, obsession, and the dark secrets people keep.
What it does well
- — Explores the devastating impact of loss and prolonged grief on a family, which can be a point of empathy for readers who have experienced similar pain.
- — Highlights the enduring love of a mother for her child, a universally relatable and positive aspect.
- — The narrative structure can be engaging for readers who enjoy suspense and mystery, encouraging critical thinking about human behavior.
Watch for
- — Contains significant dark themes including child abduction, grooming, sexual exploitation (implied), and murder, which are in stark contrast to Christian values of purity, protection of the innocent, and the sanctity of life.
- — The portrayal of morally compromised characters and the absence of clear justice or redemption for some perpetrators may be unsettling and not align with a Christian worldview that emphasizes consequences for sin and ultimate divine justice.
- — The focus on human depravity and the lack of overt Christian themes or spiritual solutions for dealing with profound suffering might leave Christian readers seeking more hope or a God-centered perspective.
Verdict
Christian readers should approach 'Then She Was Gone' with discernment. While it offers a compelling mystery and explores the depths of human grief, its dark subject matter, moral ambiguities, and lack of redemptive themes may be disturbing. It is not recommended for those seeking uplifting or faith-affirming content, and readers should be prepared for themes that directly conflict with Christian values.
ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
“Christian readers should approach 'Then She Was Gone' with discernment. While it offers a compelling mystery and explores the depths of human grief, its dark subject matter, moral ambiguities, and lack of redemptive themes may be disturbing. It is not recommended for those seeking uplifting or faith-affirming content, and readers should be prepared for themes that directly conflict with Christian values.”
Biblical alignment
- —Explores the devastating impact of loss and prolonged grief on a family, which can be a point of empathy for readers who have experienced similar pain.
- —Highlights the enduring love of a mother for her child, a universally relatable and positive aspect.
- —The narrative structure can be engaging for readers who enjoy suspense and mystery, encouraging critical thinking about human behavior.
Areas of concern
- —Contains significant dark themes including child abduction, grooming, sexual exploitation (implied), and murder, which are in stark contrast to Christian values of purity, protection of the innocent, and the sanctity of life.
- —The portrayal of morally compromised characters and the absence of clear justice or redemption for some perpetrators may be unsettling and not align with a Christian worldview that emphasizes consequences for sin and ultimate divine justice.
- —The focus on human depravity and the lack of overt Christian themes or spiritual solutions for dealing with profound suffering might leave Christian readers seeking more hope or a God-centered perspective.
- —Explores infidelity and illicit relationships without clear moral condemnation, which can be problematic from a Christian perspective on marriage and sexual ethics.
Topics
Written for