Back
    Book Review

    The Song of Achilles

    by Madeline Miller

    Read if you're interested in relationships, grief, or books for adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    3.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    Madeline Miller's 'The Song of Achilles' retells the Trojan War from the perspective of Patroclus, focusing on his deep and intimate relationship with the legendary warrior Achilles. It explores themes of love, fate, honor, and the tragic consequences of war within the framework of Greek mythology.

    What it does well
    • Explores profound human emotions such as love, devotion, and grief often found in the human experience, which can resonate with Christian understanding of the human condition.
    • Showcases the devastating consequences of war and unchecked pride, aligning with Christian calls for peace and humility.
    • The depth of relationship portrayed can prompt reflection on the nature of unconditional love and sacrifice, albeit in a non-Christian context.
    Watch for
    • The central romantic relationship is homosexual, which conflicts with traditional biblical teachings on marriage and sexuality.
    • Presents a polytheistic worldview, central to Greek mythology, which is contrary to Christian monotheism.
    • Contains explicit sexual content and mature themes that may be unsuitable for some Christian readers, especially younger audiences.
    Verdict

    Christian readers should approach 'The Song of Achilles' with caution and discernment. While it offers insights into human emotion and the tragedies of war, its foundational pagan worldview, explicit content, and portrayal of non-biblical sexual relationships make it challenging for those seeking Biblically-aligned material. It is not recommended for younger readers or those sensitive to mature themes. Adult readers who are firm in their faith and capable of critical engagement with differing worldviews may find it offers literary merit but should be prepared to filter its content through a Christian lens.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers should approach 'The Song of Achilles' with caution and discernment. While it offers insights into human emotion and the tragedies of war, its foundational pagan worldview, explicit content, and portrayal of non-biblical sexual relationships make it challenging for those seeking Biblically-aligned material. It is not recommended for younger readers or those sensitive to mature themes. Adult readers who are firm in their faith and capable of critical engagement with differing worldviews may find it offers literary merit but should be prepared to filter its content through a Christian lens.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores profound human emotions such as love, devotion, and grief often found in the human experience, which can resonate with Christian understanding of the human condition.
    • Showcases the devastating consequences of war and unchecked pride, aligning with Christian calls for peace and humility.
    • The depth of relationship portrayed can prompt reflection on the nature of unconditional love and sacrifice, albeit in a non-Christian context.
    Areas of concern
    • The central romantic relationship is homosexual, which conflicts with traditional biblical teachings on marriage and sexuality.
    • Presents a polytheistic worldview, central to Greek mythology, which is contrary to Christian monotheism.
    • Contains explicit sexual content and mature themes that may be unsuitable for some Christian readers, especially younger audiences.
    • Focuses on ancient pagan concepts of fate, honor, and divine intervention that are not aligned with a Christian understanding of God's sovereignty, free will, and morality.
    • Violence and graphic depictions of warfare are prevalent throughout the narrative.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…