Back
    Book Review

    The Shadows (The Books of Elsewhere #1)

    by Jacqueline West

    Read if you're interested in fantasy, or books for child.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    Eleven-year-old Olive Dunwoody is bored until her parents move them to a strange old house, which she soon discovers is not what it seems. Through an antique mirror, Olive can enter a magical world hidden within paintings, where she uncovers secrets and dangers related to the house's mysterious past inhabitants.

    What it does well
    • The book promotes curiosity and imagination, which can be seen as gifts from God.
    • Themes of bravery and standing up to evil are present, aligning with Christian calls to righteousness.
    • The protagonist's desire to understand and help others can be seen as positive, empathetic traits.
    Watch for
    • The central premise involves entering magical worlds through paintings and interacting with spirits/shadows, which can delve into occult-adjacent themes that may be problematic for some Christian families.
    • There is an underlying sense of magic and unexplained powers that are not rooted in a Christian worldview.
    • The 'shadows' themselves are depicted as a malevolent force, but their nature and origin are not explored through a biblical lens, which could lead to confusion for young readers regarding spiritual warfare.
    Verdict

    Christian readers, especially parents, should exercise discernment. While it offers an engaging fantasy narrative, the magical elements and interactions with unseen forces might require discussion to contextualize within a biblical framework, or may be best avoided if sensitive to such themes. It could be read with an adult to discuss the fictional nature of the magic versus spiritual truths.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers, especially parents, should exercise discernment. While it offers an engaging fantasy narrative, the magical elements and interactions with unseen forces might require discussion to contextualize within a biblical framework, or may be best avoided if sensitive to such themes. It could be read with an adult to discuss the fictional nature of the magic versus spiritual truths.
    Biblical alignment
    • The book promotes curiosity and imagination, which can be seen as gifts from God.
    • Themes of bravery and standing up to evil are present, aligning with Christian calls to righteousness.
    • The protagonist's desire to understand and help others can be seen as positive, empathetic traits.
    Areas of concern
    • The central premise involves entering magical worlds through paintings and interacting with spirits/shadows, which can delve into occult-adjacent themes that may be problematic for some Christian families.
    • There is an underlying sense of magic and unexplained powers that are not rooted in a Christian worldview.
    • The 'shadows' themselves are depicted as a malevolent force, but their nature and origin are not explored through a biblical lens, which could lead to confusion for young readers regarding spiritual warfare.
    • The characters resort to magic and supernatural means to solve problems, rather than prayer, faith, or seeking divine guidance.
    Topics
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…