Back
    Book Review

    The Land of Forgotten Girls

    by Erin Entrada Kelly

    Read if you're interested in relationships, family, or books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This novel tells the story of two Filipino-American sisters, Sol and Ming, sent to live with their estranged grandmother in the Philippines after their father's death. It explores themes of family, cultural identity, loss, and the search for belonging against the backdrop of Filipino folk tales and traditions.

    What it does well
    • Explores themes of family loyalty and sisterly bonds, which can resonate with Christian values of relational importance.
    • Highlights the importance of cultural heritage and understanding one's roots.
    • Addresses grief and loss in a sensitive manner, offering ways characters cope with hardship.
    Watch for
    • The focus on Filipino folklore and mythical creatures, while culturally significant, does not align directly with Christian spiritual beliefs and could potentially be a point of confusion for some readers regarding spiritual truth.
    • The portrayal of family dynamics, while realistic, includes strained relationships and difficult circumstances that may require discernment for younger or more sensitive readers.
    • The book does not explicitly offer Christian perspectives or solutions to the characters' struggles, which some Christian readers might find lacking.
    Verdict

    Christian readers, particularly young adult readers, could find value in the book's exploration of family, grief, and cultural identity. However, it is important to approach the folklore elements with discernment, understanding them as cultural narratives rather than spiritual truths. Parents might consider discussing these aspects with younger readers.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers, particularly young adult readers, could find value in the book's exploration of family, grief, and cultural identity. However, it is important to approach the folklore elements with discernment, understanding them as cultural narratives rather than spiritual truths. Parents might consider discussing these aspects with younger readers.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores themes of family loyalty and sisterly bonds, which can resonate with Christian values of relational importance.
    • Highlights the importance of cultural heritage and understanding one's roots.
    • Addresses grief and loss in a sensitive manner, offering ways characters cope with hardship.
    • The imaginative element of Filipino folklore can stimulate discussion on the nature of truth and storytelling.
    Areas of concern
    • The focus on Filipino folklore and mythical creatures, while culturally significant, does not align directly with Christian spiritual beliefs and could potentially be a point of confusion for some readers regarding spiritual truth.
    • The portrayal of family dynamics, while realistic, includes strained relationships and difficult circumstances that may require discernment for younger or more sensitive readers.
    • The book does not explicitly offer Christian perspectives or solutions to the characters' struggles, which some Christian readers might find lacking.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…