Back
    Book Review

    The Girl Who Drank The Moon

    by Kelly Regan Barnhill

    Read if you're interested in spiritual growth, or books for child.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.8
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This Newbery Medal-winning fantasy novel tells the story of Luna, a girl accidentally enchanted with moonlight by a kind witch, leading to a magical and perilous journey of self-discovery, love, and confronting ancient evils that have long afflicted her world.

    What it does well
    • Explores themes of sacrificial love, particularly through the character of Luna's mother, which can resonate with Christian concepts of selfless love.
    • Highlights the importance of truth and challenging long-held, harmful traditions, reflecting a biblical call to discernment and justice.
    • Features characters who act out of compassion and a desire to help others, even at great personal cost.
    Watch for
    • The magical system is central to the narrative, featuring witches, magic, and enchanted elements, which some Christian readers may find problematic or contrary to biblical warnings against witchcraft.
    • The world-building involves ancient, powerful beings whose existence and influence are not rooted in a biblical worldview but rather fantasy mythology.
    • The concept of 'drinking the moon' and gaining magical powers might be seen as glorifying non-biblical supernatural abilities.
    Verdict

    Christian readers can approach 'The Girl Who Drank The Moon' as a metaphorical fantasy story that touches on universal themes of love, truth, and hope. While its magical elements may be a concern for some due to biblical injunctions against witchcraft, the underlying moral messages of selflessness and challenging injustice can be appreciated. Parents should exercise discernment based on their family's comfort level with fantasy magic and discuss the book's themes with younger readers.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers can approach 'The Girl Who Drank The Moon' as a metaphorical fantasy story that touches on universal themes of love, truth, and hope. While its magical elements may be a concern for some due to biblical injunctions against witchcraft, the underlying moral messages of selflessness and challenging injustice can be appreciated. Parents should exercise discernment based on their family's comfort level with fantasy magic and discuss the book's themes with younger readers.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores themes of sacrificial love, particularly through the character of Luna's mother, which can resonate with Christian concepts of selfless love.
    • Highlights the importance of truth and challenging long-held, harmful traditions, reflecting a biblical call to discernment and justice.
    • Features characters who act out of compassion and a desire to help others, even at great personal cost.
    • Emphasizes the power of hope and enduring through darkness, which aligns with Christian messages of perseverance and divine hope.
    • Ultimately, good triumphs over evil, offering a message of redemption and restoration, though not explicitly Christian in its origins.
    Areas of concern
    • The magical system is central to the narrative, featuring witches, magic, and enchanted elements, which some Christian readers may find problematic or contrary to biblical warnings against witchcraft.
    • The world-building involves ancient, powerful beings whose existence and influence are not rooted in a biblical worldview but rather fantasy mythology.
    • The concept of 'drinking the moon' and gaining magical powers might be seen as glorifying non-biblical supernatural abilities.
    • The portrayal of despair and the 'Bog' as an evil entity, while metaphorical, could be interpreted in ways that are not directly aligned with Christian understandings of spiritual warfare or sources of evil.
    • The narrative does not include any explicit Christian references or elements, and its moral framework, while positive, is secular fantasy-based.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…