Back
    Book Review

    The Clique Summer Collection

    by Lisi Harrison

    Read if you're interested in relationships, or books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    3.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This collection features several novellas centered around the girls of the 'Clique' series during their summer break, focusing on their interpersonal dramas, romantic interests, and pursuit of social status. The stories highlight the aspirations and anxieties of affluent pre-teen and teenage girls.

    What it does well
    • Explores themes of friendship and belonging, which can be positive when rooted in healthy dynamics.
    • Addresses some common teenage experiences, which could offer a point of relatability for some readers.
    Watch for
    • Promotes a strong emphasis on materialism, wealth, and consumerism as central to happiness and social standing.
    • Characters often exhibit superficiality, vanity, and a preoccupation with physical appearance and designer brands.
    • Interpersonal relationships are frequently driven by social climbing, gossip, manipulation, and exclusivity, rather than genuine care or compassion.
    Verdict

    Christian readers, particularly young girls, should approach this collection with significant discernment. While it may reflect some aspects of popular culture, its predominant themes of materialism, social climbing, and superficial relationships are largely at odds with Christian values of humility, inner beauty, genuine love, and selfless service. Parental guidance is strongly advised to discuss and critique the values presented within the stories.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers, particularly young girls, should approach this collection with significant discernment. While it may reflect some aspects of popular culture, its predominant themes of materialism, social climbing, and superficial relationships are largely at odds with Christian values of humility, inner beauty, genuine love, and selfless service. Parental guidance is strongly advised to discuss and critique the values presented within the stories.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores themes of friendship and belonging, which can be positive when rooted in healthy dynamics.
    • Addresses some common teenage experiences, which could offer a point of relatability for some readers.
    Areas of concern
    • Promotes a strong emphasis on materialism, wealth, and consumerism as central to happiness and social standing.
    • Characters often exhibit superficiality, vanity, and a preoccupation with physical appearance and designer brands.
    • Interpersonal relationships are frequently driven by social climbing, gossip, manipulation, and exclusivity, rather than genuine care or compassion.
    • Portrays a culture where bullying and social ostracism are common tactics, often without clear negative consequences or lessons learned.
    • Romantic relationships are often superficial and sometimes involve manipulative behaviors.
    • Lacks overt moral guidance or a framework for ethical decision-making, leaving readers to discern appropriate behavior from questionable actions.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…