Back
    Book Review

    Some Desperate Glory

    by Emily Tesh

    Read if you're interested in books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    5.8
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This is a dystopian space opera where a young genderqueer soldier is exiled from their militaristic, xenophobic society after a catastrophic war and forced to embark on a quest that challenges their core beliefs about identity, conflict, and humanity. The narrative explores themes of found family, breaking cycles of hatred, and the complexities of morality in a universe on the brink of collapse.

    What it does well
    • Explores complex moral dilemmas and the nature of good and evil, which can prompt reflection on ethical decision-making.
    • Highlights the dangers of blind obedience, propaganda, and dehumanization, echoing biblical warnings against idolizing authority or embracing hatred.
    • Showcases a journey of self-discovery and challenging ingrained prejudices, which can be seen as a metaphorical journey towards truth and grace.
    Watch for
    • Contains pervasive LGBTQ+ themes and characters, which may conflict with traditional Christian views on sexuality and gender identity.
    • Features significant violence, including war, torture, and destruction, which while part of the narrative, can be disturbing.
    • Includes open polyamorous relationships and sexual content, which contravenes biblical teachings on marriage and sexual purity.
    Verdict

    Christian readers should approach 'Some Desperate Glory' with significant discernment. While it presents thought-provoking themes about prejudice, war, and found family, the explicit LGBTQ+ content, polyamorous relationships, sexual content, and pervasive violence may make it unsuitable for many. Readers who are comfortable engaging with these themes from a critical and biblically informed perspective and can separate narrative elements from Christian doctrine might find some allegorical value in its exploration of identity and breaking cycles of hatred. Otherwise, it is not recommended for those seeking biblically aligned fiction.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers should approach 'Some Desperate Glory' with significant discernment. While it presents thought-provoking themes about prejudice, war, and found family, the explicit LGBTQ+ content, polyamorous relationships, sexual content, and pervasive violence may make it unsuitable for many. Readers who are comfortable engaging with these themes from a critical and biblically informed perspective and can separate narrative elements from Christian doctrine might find some allegorical value in its exploration of identity and breaking cycles of hatred. Otherwise, it is not recommended for those seeking biblically aligned fiction.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores complex moral dilemmas and the nature of good and evil, which can prompt reflection on ethical decision-making.
    • Highlights the dangers of blind obedience, propaganda, and dehumanization, echoing biblical warnings against idolizing authority or embracing hatred.
    • Showcases a journey of self-discovery and challenging ingrained prejudices, which can be seen as a metaphorical journey towards truth and grace.
    • Emphasizes the power of found family and the importance of relationships beyond biological ties, aligning with Christian values of community and love.
    Areas of concern
    • Contains pervasive LGBTQ+ themes and characters, which may conflict with traditional Christian views on sexuality and gender identity.
    • Features significant violence, including war, torture, and destruction, which while part of the narrative, can be disturbing.
    • Includes open polyamorous relationships and sexual content, which contravenes biblical teachings on marriage and sexual purity.
    • The ethical framework presented is largely humanistic, focusing on individual agency and secular morality rather than explicitly Christian or biblical principles.
    • The protagonist's journey involves questioning and rejecting deeply held beliefs, which, while a noble narrative arc for the character, could be viewed as a rejection of established order or faith from a Christian perspective.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…