Back
    Book Review

    Smile

    by Raina Telgemeier

    Read if you're interested in relationships, health, or books for child.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.8
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    Smile is a graphic memoir chronicling Raina Telgemeier's traumatic dental journey from chipped front teeth to braces, headgear, and eventually, a corrected smile, alongside the challenges of middle school friendships and self-consciousness. It's a relatable story focusing on physical and emotional struggles during adolescence.

    What it does well
    • Promotes perseverance through difficult circumstances (dental ordeal)
    • Highlights the importance of self-acceptance and navigating social pressures inherent in adolescence
    • Presents a largely wholesome and age-appropriate narrative
    Watch for
    • Lacks explicit Christian themes or biblical perspective, which might be a missed opportunity for spiritual encouragement
    • Focuses primarily on external appearance and social acceptance, which while relatable for teens, isn't balanced with a deeper internal or spiritual identity
    • Some instances of typical teenage angst and frustration, though not excessive, could be seen as dwelling on negative emotions without offering an explicit spiritual outlet
    Verdict

    While "Smile" is not a Christian book, it offers a generally positive and relatable reading experience for young Christian readers, particularly girls navigating middle school challenges. Parents can use the narrative as a springboard for discussions about God's design, seeking inner beauty, perseverance from a biblical perspective, and finding identity in Christ rather than external validation. It's a safe and engaging read, but it requires Christian discernment from parents or mentors to connect secular themes with biblical truths.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    While "Smile" is not a Christian book, it offers a generally positive and relatable reading experience for young Christian readers, particularly girls navigating middle school challenges. Parents can use the narrative as a springboard for discussions about God's design, seeking inner beauty, perseverance from a biblical perspective, and finding identity in Christ rather than external validation. It's a safe and engaging read, but it requires Christian discernment from parents or mentors to connect secular themes with biblical truths.
    Biblical alignment
    • Promotes perseverance through difficult circumstances (dental ordeal)
    • Highlights the importance of self-acceptance and navigating social pressures inherent in adolescence
    • Presents a largely wholesome and age-appropriate narrative
    • Emphasizes the value of good friendships and supportive individuals
    • Illustrates realistic challenges and emotional responses teenagers experience
    Areas of concern
    • Lacks explicit Christian themes or biblical perspective, which might be a missed opportunity for spiritual encouragement
    • Focuses primarily on external appearance and social acceptance, which while relatable for teens, isn't balanced with a deeper internal or spiritual identity
    • Some instances of typical teenage angst and frustration, though not excessive, could be seen as dwelling on negative emotions without offering an explicit spiritual outlet
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…