Back
    Book Review

    Paper Valentine

    by Brenna Yovanoff

    Read if you're interested in books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    4.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    Paper Valentine is a supernatural mystery novel centered around Hannah, a ghost who cannot remember her past, inhabiting the abandoned hospital where she died. She is drawn to the living Rae, who can somehow communicate with her, and together they try to solve the murder of a girl recently found dead, a death that seems disturbingly similar to Hannah's own.

    What it does well
      Watch for
      • The central premise revolves around a ghost, which can be inconsistent with a Christian worldview regarding the afterlife and the state of the dead. While fictional, it normalizes ideas not rooted in biblical teaching.
      • The story deals with violent death, murder, and dark magical/supernatural elements (ghosts, the ability to communicate with them, an unseen 'darkness' inhabiting the hospital) which may not be edifying for Christian readers.
      • The general tone and atmosphere are dark and unsettling, lacking overt messages of hope, redemption, or faith in God, which are often sought by Christian readers.
      Verdict

      Christian readers should approach 'Paper Valentine' with discernment. While it is a work of fiction, its supernatural elements and dark themes might not align with a desire for spiritually uplifting or biblically grounded content. It may be suitable for readers who enjoy mild horror/supernatural mystery and are able to clearly distinguish fiction from biblical truth, but it does not offer Christian lessons or themes.

      ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
      Christian readers should approach 'Paper Valentine' with discernment. While it is a work of fiction, its supernatural elements and dark themes might not align with a desire for spiritually uplifting or biblically grounded content. It may be suitable for readers who enjoy mild horror/supernatural mystery and are able to clearly distinguish fiction from biblical truth, but it does not offer Christian lessons or themes.
      Biblical alignment
        Areas of concern
        • The central premise revolves around a ghost, which can be inconsistent with a Christian worldview regarding the afterlife and the state of the dead. While fictional, it normalizes ideas not rooted in biblical teaching.
        • The story deals with violent death, murder, and dark magical/supernatural elements (ghosts, the ability to communicate with them, an unseen 'darkness' inhabiting the hospital) which may not be edifying for Christian readers.
        • The general tone and atmosphere are dark and unsettling, lacking overt messages of hope, redemption, or faith in God, which are often sought by Christian readers.
        • The nature of Hannah's existence and eventual 'resolution' (without spoiling too much) doesn't align with Christian eschatology or the hope offered through Christ's resurrection.
        Written for
        Discussion

        Reader comments

        Sign in to leave a comment.

        Loading…