One for Sorrow
Read if you're interested in coming of age, good vs evil, or books for child.
Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
5.5
VerdictRead with discernment
Loading your rating…
Book Summary
Georgie moves to a new town in 1918, during the influenza pandemic, and struggles to make friends. She eventually befriends a lonely, ostracized girl named Agatha, who later dies from the flu and returns as a ghost, seeking revenge on those who mistreated her.
ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
“Christian readers, especially parents, should be aware of the ghost story element and the non-biblical portrayal of the afterlife and spirits. While it offers discussions on empathy and the dangers of bullying, it should be approached with discernment, perhaps as a springboard to discuss biblical truths about death, spirits, and forgiveness.”
Biblical alignment
- —Explores themes of empathy and kindness towards those who are different or outcast.
- —Highlights the impact of social isolation and bullying.
- —Depicts historical context (1918 flu pandemic) which can be educational.
- —Ultimately shows the destructive nature of unresolved anger and the importance of forgiveness (though not explicitly Christian).
Areas of concern
- —The central premise involves a vengeful ghost, which is not aligned with Christian understanding of the afterlife.
- —Promotes a folkloric/supernatural understanding of spirits that can be misleading.
- —While it touches on the importance of kindness, the resolution isn't rooted in biblical principles of repentance or divine justice.
- —The story may be frightening for younger or sensitive readers due to its ghost story nature.
Discussion
Reader comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
Loading…