Back
    Book Review

    On the Fence

    by Kasie West

    Read if you're interested in relationships, self-help, or books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This young adult novel follows Charlotte, a tomboy who cross-dresses as a boy to get a job at a comic book store, exploring themes of identity, friendship, and first love. As she navigates her dual life, she begins to question her perceptions of herself and others, especially her best friend, Braden.

    What it does well
    • Explores themes of self-discovery and embracing one's true identity, which can be loosely mirrored with finding identity in Christ.
    • Highlights the value of strong friendships and supportive relationships.
    • Promotes healthy communication as characters work through misunderstandings.
    Watch for
    • The premise of cross-dressing and deception, while ultimately resolved, raises questions about honesty and integrity.
    • Romantic subplots, while mild, are the central focus rather than spiritual growth or God-honoring relationships.
    • The book does not explicitly incorporate Christian faith or biblical principles, relying on secular moral frameworks.
    Verdict

    While "On the Fence" is a generally wholesome young adult novel with positive messages about friendship and identity, Christian readers should be aware of its secular nature and the premise involving deception. It can be read for entertainment and discussions about self-discovery, but spiritual insights will need to be drawn or supplemented from other sources. Parents may want to discuss themes of honesty and authenticity with their teens.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    While "On the Fence" is a generally wholesome young adult novel with positive messages about friendship and identity, Christian readers should be aware of its secular nature and the premise involving deception. It can be read for entertainment and discussions about self-discovery, but spiritual insights will need to be drawn or supplemented from other sources. Parents may want to discuss themes of honesty and authenticity with their teens.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores themes of self-discovery and embracing one's true identity, which can be loosely mirrored with finding identity in Christ.
    • Highlights the value of strong friendships and supportive relationships.
    • Promotes healthy communication as characters work through misunderstandings.
    • Generally wholesome and avoids explicit content, making it suitable for young readers.
    • Characters learn to look beyond superficial appearances and stereotypes.
    Areas of concern
    • The premise of cross-dressing and deception, while ultimately resolved, raises questions about honesty and integrity.
    • Romantic subplots, while mild, are the central focus rather than spiritual growth or God-honoring relationships.
    • The book does not explicitly incorporate Christian faith or biblical principles, relying on secular moral frameworks.
    • Some instances of teenage angst and minor rebellion against parental expectations, though not extreme.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…