Back
    Book Review

    None of This Is True

    by Lisa Jewell

    Read if you're interested in books for adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    2.5
    VerdictNot recommended
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This psychological thriller follows Josie Fair and Alix Summer, two women whose lives become dangerously intertwined after a chance encounter. What begins as a podcast project quickly devolves into a manipulative and disturbing exploration of identity, deception, and hidden pasts, with tragic and violent consequences.

    What it does well
      Watch for
      • The narrative centers heavily on themes of manipulation, obsession, and psychological distress, which can be unsettling and unedifying for Christian readers.
      • The book contains significant dark themes, including violence, murder, child abuse (implied/discussed), and disturbing psychological states, which are directly contrary to messages of hope, peace, and purity.
      • Morally ambiguous characters and actions are prevalent, with a lack of clear consequences or redemptive arcs, potentially normalizing or desensitizing readers to harmful behaviors.
      Verdict

      Christian readers seeking uplifting, morally clear, or spiritually enriching content should avoid 'None of This Is True.' Its dark themes, moral ambiguity, and focus on manipulation and violence are not aligned with Christian values or a desire for spiritual edification. It may be suitable only for those who can critically engage with dark fiction and are discerning about content, understanding it as a secular exploration of human depravity, without seeking spiritual benefit.

      ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
      Christian readers seeking uplifting, morally clear, or spiritually enriching content should avoid 'None of This Is True.' Its dark themes, moral ambiguity, and focus on manipulation and violence are not aligned with Christian values or a desire for spiritual edification. It may be suitable only for those who can critically engage with dark fiction and are discerning about content, understanding it as a secular exploration of human depravity, without seeking spiritual benefit.
      Biblical alignment
        Areas of concern
        • The narrative centers heavily on themes of manipulation, obsession, and psychological distress, which can be unsettling and unedifying for Christian readers.
        • The book contains significant dark themes, including violence, murder, child abuse (implied/discussed), and disturbing psychological states, which are directly contrary to messages of hope, peace, and purity.
        • Morally ambiguous characters and actions are prevalent, with a lack of clear consequences or redemptive arcs, potentially normalizing or desensitizing readers to harmful behaviors.
        • There is an absence of any Christian worldview, moral compass, or redemptive elements, making it difficult to find spiritual value or upliftment.
        • The sexual content, while not overly explicit, is present and contributes to the mature themes, failing to align with biblical calls for sexual purity and discretion.
        • The story glorifies deception and psychological torment, offering no path towards healing, forgiveness, or spiritual resolution.
        Written for
        Discussion

        Reader comments

        Sign in to leave a comment.

        Loading…