Book Review
Murder on the Orient Express
Read if you're interested in books for adult.
Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
5.5
VerdictRead with discernment
Loading your rating…
Book Summary
This classic mystery novel follows Detective Hercule Poirot as he investigates the murder of a wealthy American businessman aboard a snowbound train. The intricate plot reveals a collective act of vengeance carried out by several passengers against a man who evaded justice for a horrific crime.
What it does well
- — Explores themes of justice and injustice, prompting reflection on human law versus divine law.
- — Highlights the human desire for retribution when legal systems fail.
- — Showcases a brilliant intellectual puzzle, stimulating logical thought and deduction.
Watch for
- — The resolution involves all the murderers being exonerated and allowed to escape punishment, which stands in stark contrast to biblical principles of justice and consequence for sin. While the victim was evil, the act of murder by the passengers is still presented as a justifiable or understandable course of action.
- — The central theme of vigilante justice, even when morally provoked, is problematic from a Christian ethical standpoint which emphasizes God's sovereignty over justice and the call to love enemies (Romans 12:19, Matthew 5:38-48).
- — Poirot's decision to allow the murderers to go free, despite knowing the truth, presents a moral compromise that deviates from upholding truth and justice.
Verdict
Christian readers can enjoy this book as a masterfully crafted mystery for its intellectual challenge and intricate plotting. However, they should engage with the story critically, discerning the moral implications of vigilante justice and contrasting earthly justice with God's perfect justice and sovereignty.
ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
“Christian readers can enjoy this book as a masterfully crafted mystery for its intellectual challenge and intricate plotting. However, they should engage with the story critically, discerning the moral implications of vigilante justice and contrasting earthly justice with God's perfect justice and sovereignty.”
Biblical alignment
- —Explores themes of justice and injustice, prompting reflection on human law versus divine law.
- —Highlights the human desire for retribution when legal systems fail.
- —Showcases a brilliant intellectual puzzle, stimulating logical thought and deduction.
- —Does not contain explicit sexual content or gratuitous violence.
Areas of concern
- —The resolution involves all the murderers being exonerated and allowed to escape punishment, which stands in stark contrast to biblical principles of justice and consequence for sin. While the victim was evil, the act of murder by the passengers is still presented as a justifiable or understandable course of action.
- —The central theme of vigilante justice, even when morally provoked, is problematic from a Christian ethical standpoint which emphasizes God's sovereignty over justice and the call to love enemies (Romans 12:19, Matthew 5:38-48).
- —Poirot's decision to allow the murderers to go free, despite knowing the truth, presents a moral compromise that deviates from upholding truth and justice.
Written for
Discussion
Reader comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
Loading…