Back
    Book Review

    Keeper of the Lost Cities

    by Shannon Messenger

    Read if you're interested in books for young adult.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    6.8
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This book introduces Sophie Foster, a telepathic girl who discovers she is an elf and is whisked away to a hidden magical world. She navigates new schools, complex magical abilities, and a looming mystery involving a shadowy organization, all while trying to understand her identity and place in this new society.

    What it does well
    • Themes of finding one's identity and belonging, which can resonate with Christian teachings about identity in Christ.
    • Sophie's strong moral compass and desire to do what is right, even when difficult.
    • Emphasis on friendship, loyalty, and standing up for others.
    Watch for
    • The presence of magic, telepathy, and other supernatural abilities that are not Biblically grounded. While fantasy, some Christian readers may find this problematic.
    • The societal structure and the 'Lost Cities' operate completely outside of any recognition of God or a divine creator, which is typical for secular fantasy but worth noting.
    • Some instances of deception and secrecy, even if for 'good' reasons, which could be discussed from a Christian ethical standpoint.
    Verdict

    Christian readers, particularly parents of young readers, should approach 'Keeper of the Lost Cities' with discernment. While entertaining and morally sound in many respects, the pervasive magic and absence of a divine framework should be discussed within a Christian worldview. It can be enjoyed as fictional entertainment if balanced with good spiritual teaching.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers, particularly parents of young readers, should approach 'Keeper of the Lost Cities' with discernment. While entertaining and morally sound in many respects, the pervasive magic and absence of a divine framework should be discussed within a Christian worldview. It can be enjoyed as fictional entertainment if balanced with good spiritual teaching.
    Biblical alignment
    • Themes of finding one's identity and belonging, which can resonate with Christian teachings about identity in Christ.
    • Sophie's strong moral compass and desire to do what is right, even when difficult.
    • Emphasis on friendship, loyalty, and standing up for others.
    • Exploration of adoption and blended families, though in a fantastic context, can offer avenues for discussion.
    Areas of concern
    • The presence of magic, telepathy, and other supernatural abilities that are not Biblically grounded. While fantasy, some Christian readers may find this problematic.
    • The societal structure and the 'Lost Cities' operate completely outside of any recognition of God or a divine creator, which is typical for secular fantasy but worth noting.
    • Some instances of deception and secrecy, even if for 'good' reasons, which could be discussed from a Christian ethical standpoint.
    • The elves in this world are depicted as superior and separate from humans, which could be seen as promoting an elitist worldview if not discussed carefully.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…