Book Review
Five Children and It
by Edith Nesbit
Read if you're interested in books for child.
Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
6.8
VerdictRead with discernment
Loading your rating…
Book Summary
This classic children's fantasy novel follows five siblings who discover a magical, wish-granting creature called a Psammead. Their wishes invariably lead to humorous and challenging predicaments, teaching them lessons about consequences and the true value of things.
What it does well
- — Highlights the importance of children's imagination and wonder.
- — Shows natural consequences of selfish or poorly thought-out desires.
- — Promotes themes of sibling love, cooperation, and family unity, even amidst squabbles.
Watch for
- — The magic system is purely pagan/fantasy-based, with no reference to divine power or providence.
- — Moral lessons are often learned through trial-and-error and natural consequences rather than from internal conviction rooted in biblical principles.
- — Some instances of childish mischief could be seen as disobedience without clear negative repercussions within the narrative's moral framework (though consequences often follow).
Verdict
This is a classic children's tale that can be enjoyed with an understanding that its moral framework is secular, focusing on natural consequences and human ingenuity. Christian parents can use the stories as conversation starters about the wisdom of wishes, the dangers of greed, and the ultimate source of true blessing, contrasting the Psammead's magic with God's loving provision.
ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
“This is a classic children's tale that can be enjoyed with an understanding that its moral framework is secular, focusing on natural consequences and human ingenuity. Christian parents can use the stories as conversation starters about the wisdom of wishes, the dangers of greed, and the ultimate source of true blessing, contrasting the Psammead's magic with God's loving provision.”
Biblical alignment
- —Highlights the importance of children's imagination and wonder.
- —Shows natural consequences of selfish or poorly thought-out desires.
- —Promotes themes of sibling love, cooperation, and family unity, even amidst squabbles.
- —Emphasizes the idea that true happiness doesn't come from material possessions or quick fixes.
- —Gentle and generally wholesome family entertainment.
Areas of concern
- —The magic system is purely pagan/fantasy-based, with no reference to divine power or providence.
- —Moral lessons are often learned through trial-and-error and natural consequences rather than from internal conviction rooted in biblical principles.
- —Some instances of childish mischief could be seen as disobedience without clear negative repercussions within the narrative's moral framework (though consequences often follow).
- —Minor instances of fantastical creatures and mythical elements that might not be aligned with a strictly literal biblical worldview for some readers.
Discussion
Reader comments
Sign in to leave a comment.
Loading…