Back
    Book Review

    רוחות

    by Raina Telgemeier

    Read if you're interested in grief, family, or books for child.

    Buy on AmazonAs an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
    5.5
    VerdictRead with discernment
    Loading your rating…
    Book Summary

    This graphic novel tells the story of Catrina and her family who move to a new town for her younger sister Maya's cystic fibrosis, where they discover the town is filled with ghosts. While Maya embraces the supernatural, Catrina struggles to understand and accept this new reality.

    What it does well
    • Explores themes of family love and care, particularly in dealing with a sibling's chronic illness.
    • Highlights the importance of community and finding belonging in a new place.
    • Addresses the difficult topic of death and the different ways people cope with loss and the unknown.
    Watch for
    • The central theme revolves around communication with, and acceptance of, ghosts, which can introduce concepts that conflict with a biblical worldview regarding the dead and spiritual realms (Deuteronomy 18:10-12, Isaiah 8:19-20).
    • Presents ghosts as generally benign or even friendly entities, which can desensitize readers to the biblical warnings against engaging with spirits or seeking guidance from the dead.
    • While not overtly anti-Christian, the book's narrative normalized practices and beliefs concerning the supernatural that are not aligned with Christian discernment.
    Verdict

    Christian readers, especially parents considering this for children, should approach 'Guts' with discernment. While it has positive messages about family and coping with illness, its central premise regarding ghosts is problematic from a biblical perspective. It could be read with heavy parental guidance and discussion to address the spiritual implications and provide a contrasting Christian viewpoint on death and the supernatural.

    ALIGNMYREAD RECOMMENDATION
    Christian readers, especially parents considering this for children, should approach 'Guts' with discernment. While it has positive messages about family and coping with illness, its central premise regarding ghosts is problematic from a biblical perspective. It could be read with heavy parental guidance and discussion to address the spiritual implications and provide a contrasting Christian viewpoint on death and the supernatural.
    Biblical alignment
    • Explores themes of family love and care, particularly in dealing with a sibling's chronic illness.
    • Highlights the importance of community and finding belonging in a new place.
    • Addresses the difficult topic of death and the different ways people cope with loss and the unknown.
    • Portrays a strong sibling bond and the challenges of supporting a loved one through ongoing health issues.
    Areas of concern
    • The central theme revolves around communication with, and acceptance of, ghosts, which can introduce concepts that conflict with a biblical worldview regarding the dead and spiritual realms (Deuteronomy 18:10-12, Isaiah 8:19-20).
    • Presents ghosts as generally benign or even friendly entities, which can desensitize readers to the biblical warnings against engaging with spirits or seeking guidance from the dead.
    • While not overtly anti-Christian, the book's narrative normalized practices and beliefs concerning the supernatural that are not aligned with Christian discernment.
    • The book doesn't offer a Christian perspective on death, the afterlife, or spiritual realities, potentially leaving young readers with a secular or New Age understanding of these profound topics.
    Written for
    Discussion

    Reader comments

    Sign in to leave a comment.

    Loading…